The case, decided August 28, 2025, revolves around a dispute between homeowner Denise Blumberg and Security First Insurance Company. In March 2022, Blumberg purchased a one-year property insurance policy from Security First. That summer, her property suffered damage covered by the policy. When Security First declined to pay the full amount of her claim, Blumberg filed a breach-of-contract lawsuit in July 2023. The parties eventually settled the underlying claim, but left the issue of attorney’s fees unresolved.