The case, decided by the Louisiana Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal on September 29, 2025, centered on a failed property development in New Orleans East. In 2008, Henry L. Klein, the Succession of Frederick P. Heisler, and Levy Gardens Partners 2007 LP purchased property with the intention of building a multi-family housing complex. To protect their investment, they obtained three title insurance policies through Lewis Title Insurance Company, with the policies issued by Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company.